Saturday, April 23, 2011


By Chris Wilson

PART-TIME INDIAN is not a comic, or the fancier-named graphic novel. Do not be misled. It is young adult novel with smatterings of comic elements and illustrations in a very Diary of a Wimpy Kid art style. So why read and review it?

I read it because …
  1. It was a banned book, making headlines in my area.
  2. Forty pages into the book my wife was laughing one moment and in tears the next. When she read me the passage on masturbation, I had to read it myself.

I reviewed it because …
  1. The main character, Junior, talks about writing his own comics.
  2. It depicts a few comic elements and even some comic panels.

PART-TIME INDIAN is by no means a cute little teen read with happy teens doing nice things. That is exactly what makes it a worthwhile read. Junior, a high school boy on the reservation realizes that to get out of his culture of poverty, depression and despair he needs better schooling. So he leaves his school –- which is interpreted by those on the reservation as rejecting his family, community and Native American culture –– to attend the white school in the next town. He ends up playing basketball for the white school and playing against his reservation school. Oh how teenaged life sucks sometimes.

Junior’s entire story explores the gap between worlds, and the judgments he receives from the Native Americans and the Whites, both good and bad. His story is filled with bullying, ostracizing, girls, basketball, and expectations, both low and high.

What you really need to know about PART-TIME INDIAN is that it is a real novel about real teens doing real things. They talk like teens, act like teens and think like teens. It is honest and painful and riotous. It is the kind of novel teens need to read in order to explore the big wide world and the problems and complications we have. Teens will relate, even if they are not Native American, because Junior is a normal, everyday kid who recognizes he wants a better life.

It is filled with words like “pussy”, “masturbation”, and all kinds of teen-talk. It’s enough to infuriate some families and calls for bans, despite the fact that every boy over the age of 13 masturbates as if it is a requirement to get a driver’s license, and profanity is a teen-typical past time.

“Yep, I have to admit that isosceles triangles make me feel hormonal. Most guys, no matter what age, get excited about curves and circles, but not me. Don’t get me wrong, I like girls and their curves. And I really like women and their curvier curves. I spend hours in the bathroom with a magazine that has one thousand pictures of naked movie stars: Naked women + right hand = happy happy joy joy. Yep, that’s right. I admit that I masturbate. I’m proud of it. I’m good at it. I’m ambidextrous. If there were a Professional Masturbators League, I’d get drafted number one and make millions of dollars. And maybe you’re thinking, ‘Well, you really shouldn’t be talking about masturbation in public.’ Well, tough, I’m going to talk about it because EVERYBODY does it. And EVERYBODY likes it. And if God hadn’t wanted us to masturbate, then God wouldn’t have given us thumbs. But, the thing is, no matter how much time my thumbs and I spend with the curves of imaginary women, I am much more in love with the right angles of buildings.”

It is just this kind of frank expression that will help teens relate to the book. There is so much to learn –– academically and socially –– in PART-TIME INDIAN. It is a shame to not expose kids to such powerful literature.

Beyond that, the overarching theme is the fact that Junior recognizes his family and community on the reservation is depressed, alcoholic, even abusive. Junior understands the ramifications of leaving his community and his culture, yet knows he needs a better life than what rez life provides.

“Back on the rez, I was a decent player, I guess. A rebounder and a guy who could run up and down the floor without tripping. But something magical happened to me when I went to Reardon. Overnight, I became a good player. I suppose it had something to do with confidence. I mean, I’d always been the lowest Indian on the reservation totem pole –– I wasn’t expected to be good so I wasn’t. But in Readan, my coach and the other players wanted me to be good. They needed me to be good. They expected me to be good. And so I became good. I wanted to live up to expectations. I guess that’s why what it comes down to."

Chris’ Rating: High school and older

This New York Times Bestseller and National Book Award winner has also been banned in some schools, mostly for its profanity and talk of masturbation.

Despite the profanity and sexual descriptions, the book is as high quality young adult literature as you will find anywhere. The literary and real-world implications are enormous. Of course, one must understand his or her school community before embarking on such a controversial book. If it can be used then it should be.

Author: Sherman Alexie
Illustrator: Ellen Forney
Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
Genre: Illustrated Novel

Format: Hardcover
Color: Black and white
ISBN-13: 978-0-316-01368-0

Highly Recommended with Reservations
If I were in charge of the Young Adult canon of must-read novels, PART-TIME DIARY would be at the top of the list with stars and underlines.

1 comment:

Mike R. said...

I read this in my Adolescent Literature class, and it was by far my favorite book we read. Absolutely excellent.